New York City's Revised Fair Chance Rules Take Effect October 30, 2026: What Employers Need to Know

New York City's revised Fair Chance Act rules take effect October 30, 2026. Many obligations date to 2021, but the rules clarify individualized assessments, notices, response periods, reconsideration and enforcement.

Tyler Browne 13 min read

New York City's revised Fair Chance Act regulations take effect October 30, 2026, clarifying how employers must evaluate criminal history and documenting specific practices that constitute violations. Although many underlying obligations have applied since 2021, the finalized rules provide more detailed instructions on individualized assessments, candidate notices, reconsideration and enforcement.

The New York City Commission on Human Rights approved the rules on September 15, 2026, and published them in the City Record on September 30, 2026. They amend Title 47 of the Rules of the City of New York, sections 2-01 and 2-04.

The Fair Chance Act itself hasn't changed since Local Law 4 of 2021. The five-business-day response period, the protections for current employees and the limits on non-conviction records all trace back to those 2021 amendments. What changes on October 30 is how precisely the Commission spells out employers' obligations, from the first job posting to the final decision, along with a list of per se violations and the end of the early resolution option. For most employers, that is a reason to revisit an existing process, not to build a new one.

The rules apply to NYC employers with four or more employees, as well as employment agencies and their agents. They protect applicants, current employees, interns, freelancers and independent contractors.

Checklist for NYC employers

  • Remove every pre-offer reference to criminal history from NYC applications, including multistate templates that rely on "don't answer in NYC" disclaimers.
  • Take "background check required" out of NYC job postings unless another law explicitly requires it. Consider adding language that encourages people with records to apply.
  • Tell recruiters they may answer if a candidate asks whether a check is run, but shouldn't bring it up themselves.
  • Confirm that all non-criminal screening is complete before the conditional offer.
  • Classify each record accurately as a conviction, pending case or non-conviction, and have a process for correcting disposition errors.
  • Keep non-convictions away from decision-makers. That includes ACDs, violations, youthful offender adjudications, dismissals, sealed records and out-of-state equivalents.
  • Apply the right factors: Article 23-A for pre-employment convictions, the seven NYC factors for pending cases and matters arising during employment.
  • Update your Fair Chance notice to give facts for each factor, the outcome, the basis for the decision and response instructions. Add a seven-factor version for pending cases and current employees.
  • Start the response clock only once the person has received both the notice and a full copy of everything relied on. Treat five business days as the minimum and consider reasonable requests for more time.
  • Add a re-analysis step for when a candidate shows a material error, and a written communication when you proceed with adverse action after reviewing the person's response.
  • Confirm that any applicable FCRA adverse action notices are also sent.
  • Establish a procedure for paid or unpaid leave during an employee's Fair Chance review, recognizing that leave of more than five business days is presumptively unreasonable but may be justified depending on the circumstances.
  • Review any role where you rely on a legal-check or legal-bar exemption, and run the full process on the rest of the record.

What the rules cover

The sections below walk through the rules step by step.

1. Before the conditional offer

For positions subject to the ordinary Fair Chance Act screening sequence, employers generally must complete noncriminal screening before making a conditional offer and defer criminal history inquiries until after that offer. Specific statutory exemptions may permit a different sequence. What the revised rules add is a list of four pre-offer actions that are violations on their own, whether or not anyone is harmed:

  • Expressing any limitation about criminal history, including unsolicited statements that a background check will be run.
  • Asking about criminal history, asking permission to run a check, or saying that checks will be conducted.
  • Investigating criminal history yourself or through a third party, including web and "mugshot" searches.
  • Using any form or application that requests or refers to criminal history, even with a disclaimer or a note telling NYC applicants to skip the question.

Two things are now expressly allowed. Job ads may encourage people with criminal records to apply, and employers may answer an applicant who asks whether a background check will be done.

"Background check required" may not appear in an NYC job posting unless another law explicitly requires that statement. This applies even when the role is one where a check is legally mandated.

2. Which records can be considered

The rules sort records into three groups.

Record typeExamplesCan it be considered?
Conviction historyFelony or misdemeanor convictionsYes, after the Article 23-A analysis (8 factors)
Pending caseAn arrest or charge not yet resolved at the time of the analysisYes, after the NYC Fair Chance Employment Factors analysis (7 factors)
Non-convictionAdjournments in contemplation of dismissal; cases dismissed or otherwise ended in the person's favor; youthful offender adjudications; violation convictions (even if not sealed); sealed convictions; comparable out-of-state outcomesNo, unless another law requires it

An adjournment in contemplation of dismissal counts as a non-conviction, not a pending case, unless the ACD order is revoked and the case restored before the employer's analysis.

Getting the classification right matters, because it decides which process applies, or whether the record can be used at all. A dismissed case wrongly treated as a pending charge sends the review down the wrong path. An ACD can look unresolved on a report even though NYC law treats it as a non-conviction while it remains in effect. Accurate disposition classification is essential. Employers should not assume that every record appearing in a background check can lawfully be considered in an employment decision.

Protected records can still show up in screening results or otherwise reach reviewers. Employers need controls on what information is actually used in a decision, not just assumptions about what their consumer reporting agency will report.

Which factors apply. The required framework depends on the type of record and when the conduct or case arose, not simply on whether the person has a record. Pre-employment convictions are analyzed under the eight Article 23-A factors. Pending cases, and convictions or pending cases that arise during employment, are analyzed under the seven NYC Fair Chance Employment Factors. The two lists differ in ways that affect the outcome. The NYC factors ask whether the person was 25 or younger when the conduct occurred, while Article 23-A considers age at the time of the offense without that threshold. Article 23-A also expressly weighs the time elapsed since the offense. An employer using one review template or policy matrix for every record may not be applying the right test.

3. The Fair Chance Employment Process

If the results don't change the hiring decision, no analysis is needed. To withdraw an offer or take any other adverse action based on a conviction or pending case, employers must:

  1. Ask the candidate for information relevant to the factors, such as clarification, rehabilitation and good conduct. A certificate of relief from disabilities or of good conduct creates a presumption of rehabilitation.
  2. Complete the analysis. Apply the Article 23-A factors to pre-employment convictions, or the NYC factors to pending cases and matters arising during employment. Then decide whether there is a direct relationship to specific job duties or an unreasonable risk. Seriousness alone isn't enough.
  3. Send the Fair Chance notice with a copy of everything relied on. That includes the consumer report, any web printouts or public records, and written summaries of oral information. The notice must give specific facts for each factor and the outcome, explain the basis for the decision, and tell the person how and by when to respond.
  4. Allow a reasonable time to respond, and no less than five business days, counted from when the person has received both the notice and the copy. The position can't be permanently filled during that time.
  5. Consider anything the person provides, oral or written, in a new analysis.
  6. Redo the analysis if the person shows a material error, such as a wrong disposition or a case that isn't actually pending. Skipping this is now a violation on its own. If the corrected information establishes that the record is a protected non-conviction or that no relevant criminal record exists, the employer cannot take adverse action based on that information, absent an applicable statutory exception.
  7. If, after reviewing the additional information, the employer decides to proceed with the adverse action, communicate that decision in writing in a timely way.

Five business days is a minimum, not a deadline. The five-business-day period has applied since 2021. The rules call for a reasonable response period of no less than five business days, taking into account the information the person is trying to obtain, why more time is needed and other relevant circumstances. Employers should consider reasonable requests for additional time, particularly when an applicant is trying to obtain court records, correct an error or provide rehabilitation evidence. A process that automatically finalizes a rejection when a five-day timer runs out may not meet that standard.

The NYC process and the FCRA are separate. When a consumer report is involved, employers should also make sure any applicable FCRA pre-adverse and final adverse action notice requirements are satisfied. The two processes are related but not interchangeable, and meeting one doesn't satisfy the other.

Boilerplate notices don't meet these requirements. The Commission's posted Fair Chance notice dates from 2021, and its factor list is written for convictions only. Employers handling pending cases or current employees will need a notice built on the seven NYC factors.

Intentional misrepresentation. Before acting on a candidate's intentional misstatement about a conviction or pending case, an employer must share the information relied on and allow at least five business days to respond. The rules note that a gap between a self-report and a background check is not, by itself, proof of intent.

4. Current employees

The 2021 amendments extended Fair Chance protections to current employees, and the revised rules spell out the procedure. The same process applies before demoting, transferring, disciplining or terminating an employee over a pending case or a conviction during employment.

Employers may place the employee on paid or unpaid leave while the process runs. The rules presume that leave of more than five business days is unreasonable, but longer leave may be justified depending on the circumstances. Leave that meets these terms isn't treated as an adverse action under the Fair Chance framework. That exclusion is specific to the Fair Chance rules and doesn't protect against claims under other employment laws.

5. Exemptions are narrower

Employers must prove that an exemption applies to each specific action for each person.

  • A law requires a background check but doesn't bar the person. You may run the check before the offer, but the full process still applies before any adverse action.
  • A law bars employment for a specific offense. You may act on that offense without the analysis. Everything else in the report still goes through the full process, and the exemption is lost if the bar was removed by a pardon or certificate.
  • FINRA and other self-regulatory organization rules count as federal law for these exemptions, but only for regulated positions.
  • An exemption relied on in error means the action is judged under the full rules.

6. Enforcement

The Commission removed its early resolution option. That option let employers with 50 or fewer employees settle Commission-initiated complaints by admitting a violation and paying a set fine. These cases now proceed like any other Human Rights Law matter.

Revoking a conditional offer without following the process creates a presumption that criminal history was the reason. An employer can rebut it only by showing the decision rested on a permitted medical exam, material information it couldn't reasonably have known before the offer, or no knowledge of the record.

What an NYC review looks like in practice

Consider an employer hiring a warehouse associate. After the conditional offer, the background check returns an eight-year-old theft conviction. Here is what happens next:

  1. Identify what can legally be considered. Determine whether the result is a conviction, a pending case or a protected non-conviction. Here it is a pre-employment conviction, so the eight Article 23-A factors apply.
  2. Evaluate the record against the actual job. Consider the duties of the warehouse position, the underlying conduct, when it occurred and the remaining factors.
  3. Evaluate any basis for concern. If the employer is considering an adverse decision, it must identify the specific connection to the job or the specific risk, rather than relying on the offense label alone.
  4. Document and communicate the analysis. Provide the Fair Chance notice, the individualized explanation and a copy of the underlying information.
  5. Give the candidate an opportunity to respond. Consider corrections, rehabilitation evidence and other relevant information before making the final decision.

Illustrative workflow for a nonexempt position, not an automatic disqualification rule.

Why offense-based rules fall short. An employer's criminal history policy might flag every theft conviction for additional review. But an eight-year-old theft conviction may raise different considerations for a warehouse associate than for an employee responsible for managing financial accounts. The Fair Chance framework requires employers to look beyond the offense category and evaluate its relationship to the actual position, alongside the remaining factors.

Consistent policies can help employers identify which records warrant closer attention. But a policy flag is not itself a legal determination that an applicant should be disqualified.

This doesn't mean employers need to abandon consistent background-check policies. Those policies serve an important purpose by helping identify records relevant to particular job responsibilities. The challenge is ensuring that a policy flag initiates an appropriate review rather than predetermining the outcome.

What this means for employers reviewing background checks

The revised rules reinforce an important distinction: identifying a criminal record that warrants review is not the same as determining that the record justifies an adverse employment decision.

Employers need to consider what the underlying conduct actually means for the position, how much time has passed, the individual's circumstances, and any evidence of rehabilitation or good conduct. When a record raises concerns, employers also need to explain their reasoning and provide an opportunity to respond.

This can be challenging when review teams are managing large volumes of background checks, applying different policies across job types, or relying on manual adjudication processes.

Kizuna helps employers bring greater consistency and context to criminal background-check reviews. By connecting records to job-specific risk considerations, incorporating research on how risk changes over time, and supporting more structured assessments, Kizuna helps teams make better-informed decisions while retaining human judgment.

These tools can support an employer's Fair Chance review process, alongside the required legal analysis, notices, response periods, and other applicable procedures.

Official sources

Further reading

This post is an informational summary and is not legal advice. Employers should confirm their policies and processes with counsel.

See it in action

See how Kizuna brings consistency and context to criminal background-check reviews, with structured, documented assessments that support your compliance process.

Explore Compliance Tooling →

Smarter hiring starts here